Contact Us

As the #1 locally owned agency, we have 25 years of experience. Our agents will work with you to make sure you have all you need to make informed decisions.

Sales & Recently Sold

If you’re in the market for a new home, we have the resources to help you make the right decision to meet your needs. We can show you any home for sale on the Island.

Rentals

Shelter Island’s renowned location100 miles outside of New York City has it all: Tennis, golf, sailing, yoga and fitness classes. Plus world-class restaurants. Visit our listings here.

Shelter Island 2023

Whether you’re in the mood to hike, bike or just chill, Shelter Island has something for you. Visit farmer’s markets, try your hand at kayaking or learn about the Island’s history.

Melina Wein Who is M. Wein Realty?

Melina Wein started M. Wein Realty Inc. twenty-five years ago, as a full-service luxury resort real estate brokerage on Shelter Island. It is an independent, thriving company with an exceptional group of experienced real estate professionals who are knowledgeable about our island, the market and the inventory.

Learn More

What People are Saying

I had the pleasure of working with Melina during this difficult time and she was able to get our home sold while having to overcome many challenges with the town and multiple contractors. Her track record and local knowledge was what made us choose her and she outperformed our high expectations. If you are selling waterfront on Shelter Island there is no second to Melina. Tyler Cande
Melina is the best. She brought all her experience to help us with our purchase. Highly Recommended! Don on her team showed us around and was also very knowledgeable of the area. Melina always followed up in a very timely manner and helped us manage through the entire process. David Austin
Melina is the most professional real estate broker on Shelter Island. She has an intimate knowledge of the community, both from a real estate and lifestyle perspective. She will work tirelessly on your behalf whether you are buying or selling. She will be with you every step of the way, no matter how big or small the issue. I wouldn’t work with anyone else. Jennifer Ruys
Melina is lovely and easy to deal with. She was always available to us. No one knows the market better. What impressed me most was her ability to identify a serious buyer and recommend the best way to deal with the potential sale. I trusted her perspective and her negotiating skills were spot on. We successfully sold our house thanks to Melina. Ann Stonehill
Melina is a great listener and works to find properties that meet your needs; she does not push just to make a sale. Her primary goal is to have a satisfied island resident. I highly recommend her. Henry Fayne
There’s no finer Realtor than Melina Wein. In 2017 she quickly found an excellent buyer for my waterfront home and successfully navigated a more difficult negotiation for the smaller home I desired. Just a couple years later my circumstances had changed and I decided to leave the area for a while. The sales market was not particularly strong but Melina persevered and once again helped in securing a reasonable price for my property. That sale closed in July. No doubt I’ll return to Shelter Island in the coming years. Also no doubt I’ll engage my friend Melina and her wonderful team to obtain my next home there. Park Davis
M.Wein and her team continually exceeded our expectations -doing everything possible to ease the process involved in selling our home. Melina is highly professional and personable -treating us with care and concern throughout the sales cycle. Always honest and candid, she demonstrated an intimate knowledge of the local market, analyzed complex sales trends and suggested competitive, reality-based pricing strategies. Melina is well-connected to an impressive network of real estate professionals across the East End of Long Island. She held both special showings for other brokers and open houses for the general public to ensure that our listing received widespread exposure. She and her team developed well-worded descriptions of our property along with appealing photographs - and placed prominent ads in the local newspapers and on-line. She also shared detailed feedback from each prospective buyer with us after every showing. A natural problem solver, Melina's priority is her client's. Linda Paige-Levine
I had the pleasure of working with Melina during this difficult time and she was able to get our home sold while having to overcome many challenges with the town and multiple contractors. Her track record and local knowledge was what made us choose her and she outperformed our high expectations. If you are selling waterfront on Shelter Island there is no second to Melina. Tyler Cande
Melina is the best. She brought all her experience to help us with our purchase. Highly Recommended! Don on her team showed us around and was also very knowledgeable of the area. Melina always followed up in a very timely manner and helped us manage through the entire process. David Austin
Melina is the most professional real estate broker on Shelter Island. She has an intimate knowledge of the community, both from a real estate and lifestyle perspective. She will work tirelessly on your behalf whether you are buying or selling. She will be with you every step of the way, no matter how big or small the issue. I wouldn’t work with anyone else. Jennifer Ruys
Melina is lovely and easy to deal with. She was always available to us. No one knows the market better. What impressed me most was her ability to identify a serious buyer and recommend the best way to deal with the potential sale. I trusted her perspective and her negotiating skills were spot on. We successfully sold our house thanks to Melina. Ann Stonehill
Melina is a great listener and works to find properties that meet your needs; she does not push just to make a sale. Her primary goal is to have a satisfied island resident. I highly recommend her. Henry Fayne
There’s no finer Realtor than Melina Wein. In 2017 she quickly found an excellent buyer for my waterfront home and successfully navigated a more difficult negotiation for the smaller home I desired. Just a couple years later my circumstances had changed and I decided to leave the area for a while. The sales market was not particularly strong but Melina persevered and once again helped in securing a reasonable price for my property. That sale closed in July. No doubt I’ll return to Shelter Island in the coming years. Also no doubt I’ll engage my friend Melina and her wonderful team to obtain my next home there. Park Davis
M.Wein and her team continually exceeded our expectations -doing everything possible to ease the process involved in selling our home. Melina is highly professional and personable -treating us with care and concern throughout the sales cycle. Always honest and candid, she demonstrated an intimate knowledge of the local market, analyzed complex sales trends and suggested competitive, reality-based pricing strategies. Melina is well-connected to an impressive network of real estate professionals across the East End of Long Island. She held both special showings for other brokers and open houses for the general public to ensure that our listing received widespread exposure. She and her team developed well-worded descriptions of our property along with appealing photographs - and placed prominent ads in the local newspapers and on-line. She also shared detailed feedback from each prospective buyer with us after every showing. A natural problem solver, Melina's priority is her client's. Linda Paige-Levine
I had the pleasure of working with Melina during this difficult time and she was able to get our home sold while having to overcome many challenges with the town and multiple contractors. Her track record and local knowledge was what made us choose her and she outperformed our high expectations. If you are selling waterfront on Shelter Island there is no second to Melina. Tyler Cande
Melina is the best. She brought all her experience to help us with our purchase. Highly Recommended! Don on her team showed us around and was also very knowledgeable of the area. Melina always followed up in a very timely manner and helped us manage through the entire process. David Austin
Melina is the most professional real estate broker on Shelter Island. She has an intimate knowledge of the community, both from a real estate and lifestyle perspective. She will work tirelessly on your behalf whether you are buying or selling. She will be with you every step of the way, no matter how big or small the issue. I wouldn’t work with anyone else. Jennifer Ruys
Melina is lovely and easy to deal with. She was always available to us. No one knows the market better. What impressed me most was her ability to identify a serious buyer and recommend the best way to deal with the potential sale. I trusted her perspective and her negotiating skills were spot on. We successfully sold our house thanks to Melina. Ann Stonehill
Melina is a great listener and works to find properties that meet your needs; she does not push just to make a sale. Her primary goal is to have a satisfied island resident. I highly recommend her. Henry Fayne
There’s no finer Realtor than Melina Wein. In 2017 she quickly found an excellent buyer for my waterfront home and successfully navigated a more difficult negotiation for the smaller home I desired. Just a couple years later my circumstances had changed and I decided to leave the area for a while. The sales market was not particularly strong but Melina persevered and once again helped in securing a reasonable price for my property. That sale closed in July. No doubt I’ll return to Shelter Island in the coming years. Also no doubt I’ll engage my friend Melina and her wonderful team to obtain my next home there. Park Davis
M.Wein and her team continually exceeded our expectations -doing everything possible to ease the process involved in selling our home. Melina is highly professional and personable -treating us with care and concern throughout the sales cycle. Always honest and candid, she demonstrated an intimate knowledge of the local market, analyzed complex sales trends and suggested competitive, reality-based pricing strategies. Melina is well-connected to an impressive network of real estate professionals across the East End of Long Island. She held both special showings for other brokers and open houses for the general public to ensure that our listing received widespread exposure. She and her team developed well-worded descriptions of our property along with appealing photographs - and placed prominent ads in the local newspapers and on-line. She also shared detailed feedback from each prospective buyer with us after every showing. A natural problem solver, Melina's priority is her client's. Linda Paige-Levine

Melina WeinM. Wein Realty Inc.

631-749-0999 631-749-0999
34 N. Ferry Road - PO Box 1732
Shelter Island, NY 11964
info@mweinrealty.com
Quick Links
Get in Touch
Privacy Policy
Powered by linkurealty.com